Welcome to What's Cookin' Petey!
"What's Cookin' Petey!" in Lindenhurst, NY, brings an authentic taste of Puerto Rican and Cuban cuisine that delights the senses. Their offerings, including savory empanadas and flavorful chicken wings, are celebrated for their robust flavors and quality. The standout dishes like sweet plantains and yuca fries highlight the vibrant culinary traditions of the Caribbean. Patrons rave about the friendly service, enhancing the overall dining experience. With each bite, customers are transported back to cherished family memories, making this establishment a beloved addition to the local food scene. A must-visit for those seeking comfort food with an island flair!
-
646 N Wellwood Ave Units B & C, Lindenhurst, NY 11757, United States646 N Wellwood Ave Units B & C, Lindenhurst, NY 11757, United States Hotline:
Welcome to the vibrant world of What's Cookin' Petey!, a culinary gem nestled in Lindenhurst, New York, at 646 N Wellwood Ave Units B & C. This local sensation shines brightly with its mouth-watering offerings, specializing in an array of delightful empanadas that pay homage to flavors from Puerto Rican and Cuban cuisines. As you step inside, you're greeted not only by the enticing aromas but also by a team that embodies warmth and hospitality, making every visit a memorable one.
The menu at What's Cookin' Petey! showcases a spectrum of plant-based options, allowing food enthusiasts of all kinds to indulge guilt-free. The Plant-Based Beef Empanadas stand out as a favorite, served alongside complimentary rice, beans, and sweet plantains. Diners rave about the combination of flaky crust and inventive fillings, with mentions of the shrimp & mango salsa empanada eliciting curiosity for its sweet surprise, perfectly balancing savory and dessert-like qualities.
Reviewers like Nicole passionately express how the flavors evoke cherished family memories, proclaiming the food as a “taste of HEAVEN” and emphasizing the importance of supporting this local establishment. The heartfelt comments resonate deeply, suggesting that each bite transports diners to a realm of nostalgia wrapped in dough. Meanwhile, Chris M appreciates the light and flaky crust of their offerings, eagerly looking forward to revisiting to explore more of their delicious beef options.
Yet, it’s not just fantastic food that sets What's Cookin' Petey! apart; it’s the dedication to customer service. Many customers echo sentiments regarding the friendly staff, showcasing an environment that feels more like home than a typical eatery. Quackstar's Productions notably highlights the kindness of the employees, suggesting that the experience is just as gratifying as the food itself.
However, like any establishment, there’s always room for growth, as pointed out in the review by Tanya E A. Conversations with the owner, Pete, show a commitment to improvement, ensuring each customer’s voice is heard and valued. Such dedication not only enhances the dining experience but also fosters a community feeling among patrons.
In conclusion, What's Cookin' Petey! embodies a delightful blend of culinary artistry and community spirit. Whether you're here for a quick lunch or a dinner that tantalizes the taste buds, this eatery is destined to become a beloved staple in the Lindenhurst area. With a commitment to flavor, quality, and customer satisfaction, prepare your palate for a symphony of tastes that will leave you eagerly anticipating your next visit.
Let me start by saying I come from a Puerto Rican & Cuban family and all of this food is a taste of HEAVEN!! Absolutely delicious and full of FANTASTIC flavor!! Since they opened I want nothing more than to eat there every SINGLE DAY!! It is a memory of my Dad and his side of the family...I look forward to MANY MANY MANY meals and getting food catered for parties in the future...the food is a MUST and if in question you definitely NEED TO ORDER!! The owner and staff were so friendly and spectacular it is such a nice new welcome to the Lindenhurst area...Island Empanada we all look forward to seeing you in many years to come!!
Tried this place for the first time today. Got the dinner special. I got chicken with cheese, loaded potato and shrimp & mango salsa empanadas. All three were good, surrounded by a light flaky crust. The shrimp & mango salsa one was rather odd - sweet, almost like a dessert. The rice & beans was also good. I'll have to stop here again and try the beef empanadas.
UPDATE I spoke with Pete who has proven a care for his employees along with customer service being a main priority!! Thank you Pete for responding to my previous statement, it was a pleasure speaking with you. This review is not based on the quality of the food. This is based on the work ethic of the employees. Mainly a female employee who when I walked in was so sound asleep head down on the table that she didn’t hear me say hello until my sixth LOUD hello! She proceeded to get up run in the back without acknowledgement of my existence then a man came out from back took my order she came up and packed it.....
The Empanadas (pastelillos) were amazingly delicious.
Food was great but the staffs kindness was even better. I met one of the owners at the bagel store and he was so kind and knowledgeable it made me go order empanadas after I already order our bagels. Even during grand opening madness they were attentive to every customer and made sure every one was happy before the left. Again it helps that everything was absolutely delicious.
The food was delicious, especially the Chicken Bacon Ranch empanada! The rice, beans, and sweet plantains were also very tasty! The staff was quick and very professional, will definitely be back!
I'm so happy they opened up I additional location. These are my favorite empanadas. I want to go back already. So many varieties, even dessert options. Don't forget to try the plantains, they're sweet.
I absolutely love Island Empanada and I was so excited when I heard they were opening up one in Lindenhurst. As always the food was awesome! I always have to get the Mini Mac and Cheese balls and my absolute favorites the Spinach Feta and Spicy Cheese empanadas.