What's Cookin' Petey! Menu (2025 Update)

  1. Home
  2. Menu

Welcome to What's Cookin' Petey!, a delightful culinary gem nestled in Lindenhurst, NY. This vibrant eatery celebrates the rich flavors of Puerto Rican and Cuban cuisine, offering a menu that is both diverse and enticing. Highlights include their sweet plantains, perfectly crispy tostones, and mouthwatering empanadas filled with savory plant-based beef.

For those seeking comfort food, indulge in their mini loaded baked potato balls and creamy mac & cheese balls. The plant-based dinner special showcases a thoughtful blend of rice, beans, and sweet plantains, catering to vegans and vegetarians alike.

Customer reviews rave about the food's authenticity and the friendly service, making each visit feel welcoming and special. The combination of fantastic flavors and a warm atmosphere creates a must-visit destination for any food lover. Don't miss out on this culinary experience that promises not just a meal, but a taste of home!

All Day - Alcoholic Beverages All Day - Homemade Soup All Day - Empanadas All Day - Get'em by the Box All Day - Potato, Mac & Cheese Balls All Day - Sides All Day - Sauce All Day - Desserts All Day - Beverages All Day - Plant Based All Day - Chicken Wings Lunch - Lunch Specials Lunch - Homemade Soup Lunch - Empanadas Lunch - Got'em by the Box Lunch - Potato, Mac & Cheese Balls Lunch - Sides Lunch - Sauce Lunch - Desserts Lunch - Beverages Lunch - Plant Based Lunch - Chicken Wings Dinner - Dinner Special Dinner - Homemade Soup Dinner - Empanadas Dinner - Got'em by the Box Dinner - Potato, Mac & Cheese Balls Dinner - Sides Dinner - Sauce Dinner - Desserts Dinner - Beverages Dinner - Plant Based Dinner - Chicken Wings

All Day - Alcoholic Beverages

Pineapple Margarita

Must purchase 1 food item. Must show valid proof of age upon delivery.
US$8.25

Homemade White Sangria

1 Food item must be purchased. Valid Proof of age must be shown upon delivery.
US$9.25

Peach Margarita

Must purchase 1 food item. Must show valid proof of age upon delivery
US$8.25

Blue Point Imperial Sunshine

Must be 21 or older to purchase. Valid proof of age required at time of delivery.
US$7.35

Blue Point Mother Pumpkin

Blue Point Mother Pumpkin
US$9.00

Blue Point Spectral Haze

Must be 21 or older to purchase. Valid proof of age required at time of delivery.
US$7.35

Chicken & Rice Soup (Large 16 Oz.)
US$6.69

Chicken & Rice Soup (Small 12 Oz.)
US$5.25

All Day - Homemade Soup

All Day - Empanadas

Traditional Beef With Cheese

Seasoned ground beef, secret sofrito sauce with cheddar cheese (con queso cheddar).
US$4.94

Traditional Chicken With Cheese

Tender shredded chicken seasoned with secret sofrito sauce with cheddar cheese. (con queso cheddar)
US$4.94

Traditional Chicken (Pollo Traditional)

Tender shredded chicken seasoned with secret sofrito sauce.
US$4.94

Buffalo Chicken (Pollo Bufallo)

Tender shredded chicken, buffalo sauce.
US$4.94

Traditional Beef (Carne Tradicional)

Seasoned ground beef, secret sofrito sauce.
US$4.94

Pork (Pernil)

Marinated, slow-cooked, Puerto Rican style.
US$4.94

Loaded Potato

Seasoned mashed potatoes, bacon, cheddar, sour cream and scallions.
US$4.94

Four Cheese (Cuatro Queso)

Queso Blanco, cheddar, mozzarella, and ricotta.
US$4.94

Philly Cheese Steak

Tender steak, peppers, onions, garlic and provolone.
US$4.94

Chicken Bacon Ranch (Pollo Ranchero)

Tender shredded chicken, bacon, ranch dressing, cheddar, and mozzarella cheese. (Aka uncle joey)
US$4.94

Bacon Mac &Cheese

Homemade mac and cheese with crispy bacon.
US$4.94

Cuban

Slow-cooked pork, ham, swiss, pickle, mustard, and mayo.
US$4.94

Spinach & Feta (Espinaca Y Queso Feta)

Spinach, feta, garlic, and onions.
US$4.94

Pastelon

Seasoned ground beef, secret sofrito sauce with cheddar cheese (con queso cheddar), sweet plantains.
US$4.94

Chipotle Beef (Carne Chipotle)

Hot. Ground beef, smokey chipotle peppers, sweet peppers, onions and garlic.
US$4.94

Shrimp & Mango Salsa (Camerones Y Salsa De Mango)

Shrimp sauteed with garlic, mango salsa, and fresh cilantro.
US$5.30

B.B.Q. Chicken (Pollo A La Barbacoa)

Tender shredded chicken, BBQ sauce, bacon, and mozzarella cheese.
US$4.94

Broccoli & Cheese (Broccoli Y Queso)

Broccoli, garlic, scallots, and cheddar.
US$4.94

Latin Shrimp (Camerones A Lo Latino)

Shrimp sauteed with peppers, onions, and Latin spices.
US$5.30

Spicy Cheese

Four cheese with spicy chopped jalapeno.
US$4.94

Nacho Empanada

Refried beans, mango salsa, and cheddar cheese.
US$4.94

Chorizo & Potato (Chorize & Pappas)

Spanish sausage, potato, peppers, onion, garil and cilantro.
US$4.94

Chipotle Chicken (Pollo Chipotle)

Hot. Tender shredded chicken, smokey chipotle peppers, sweet peppers, onions, and garlic.
US$4.94

Asian Chicken (Pollo Asiatico)

Tender shredded chicken, spicy Asian sauce.
US$4.94

Veggie Lover (Vegan)

Broccoli, carrots, peppers, onions, celery, and garlic.
US$4.94

Sweet Plantain & Mozzarella (Plantanos Maduos Y Mozzarella)

Ripe plantains with mozzarella cheese.
US$4.94

Chipotle Beef & Sweet Plantain (Carne Chipotle Y Plantanos Maduros)

Ground beef, chipotle peppers, sweet peppers, onions, garlic, and sweet plantains.
US$4.94

Any 10 Empanadas

Choose 10 empanadas.
US$44.50

Any 20 Empanadas

Choice of many flavors.
US$86.79

Any 15 Empanadas

Choice of many flavors.
US$66.89

All Day - Get'em by the Box

All Day - Potato, Mac & Cheese Balls

Mini Mac & Cheese Ball (1 Ball)

Creamy homemade mac and cheese with panko bread crumbs.
US$3.99

Mini Loaded Potato Ball (1 Ball1)

Bacon, cheddar, sour cream, and scallions.
US$3.99

Sofrito Beef

Seasoned mashed potatoes stuffed with sofrito beef.
US$6.15

Yellow Rice & Beans (Large - Grande)
US$9.75

Yellow Rice & Beans (Small - Pequeno)

Vegan, vegetarian.
US$4.85

Sweet Plantains (Small - Pequeno)
US$4.85

Tostones

A savory green plantain with a crunch.
US$4.85

Sweet Plantains (Large - Grande)
US$9.75

Chicken Tenders

4 piece. Choice of ketchup, honey mustard or no sauce.
US$9.59

French Fries

Choice of ketchup, pink sauce or no sauce.
US$4.85

Small Fiesta Fries

Fries Made from Yuca
US$4.85

Large Fiesta Fries
US$9.75

All Day - Sides

All Day - Sauce

Green Sauce 2oz Cup

Medium spice.
US$0.60

Red Sauce 2oz Cup

Spicy
US$0.60

Sour Cream 2oz Cup
US$0.60

Sour Cream 1oz Cup
US$0.40

Red Sauce 1oz Cup

Spicy.
US$0.40

Green Sauce 1oz Cup

Medium spice.
US$0.40

Oreo Empanada

Ala mode (vanilla ice cream).
US$5.30

Apple Caramel Empanada

Ala mode (vanilla ice cream).
US$5.30

Stuffed Churro

With barvarian cream.
US$3.69

Guava & Cream Cheese Empanada

Guava and cream cheese empanada.
US$5.30

Oreo Empanada (A La Mode)

Served with icecream.
US$6.50

Apple Caramel Empanada A La Mode

Served with icecream.
US$6.50

Churo Sundae With Vanilla Ice Cream
US$4.29

All Day - Desserts

All Day - Beverages

20 Oz Bottle Drinks
US$3.45

Hot Cocoa

12 oz cup
US$2.99

2 Liter Soda
US$4.29

Fountain Drink 24oz
US$3.69

Fountain Drink 16oz
US$3.09

Plant-Based Dinner Special

3 plant based empanadas,rice & beans,Sweet plantains and a fountain drink.
US$21.95

Plant Based Lunch Special With Sides

2 plant based empanadas,Sweet plantains,rice & beans and a fountain drink.
US$17.05

Plant Based Beef Empanada

Singular empanada.
US$5.89

2 Plant-Based Beef Empanadas No Sides

Served with a fountain drink.
US$13.50

All Day - Plant Based

All Day - Chicken Wings

6 Wings
US$10.90

12 Wings
US$20.59

Any 2 Empanadas With Rice & Beans, Sweet Plantains & Fountain Drink 16 Oz
US$14.85

Any 2 Empanadas & Fountain Drink (16 Oz.)
US$11.15

Lunch - Lunch Specials

Lunch - Homemade Soup

Chicken & Rice Soup (Small 12 Oz.)
US$5.25

Chicken & Rice Soup (Large 16 Oz.)
US$6.69

Traditional Beef With Cheese

Seasoned ground beef, secret sofrito sauce with cheddar cheese (con queso cheddar).
US$4.94

Traditional Chicken With Cheese

Tender shredded chicken seasoned with secret sofrito sauce with cheddar cheese. (con queso cheddar)
US$4.94

Traditional Beef (Carne Tradicional)

Seasoned ground beef, secret sofrito sauce.
US$4.94

Chicken Bacon Ranch (Pollo Ranchero)

Tender shredded chicken, bacon, ranch dressing, cheddar, and mozzarella cheese. (Aka uncle joey)
US$4.94

Traditional Chicken (Pollo Traditional)

Tender shredded chicken seasoned with secret sofrito sauce.
US$4.94

Cuban

Slow-cooked pork, ham, swiss, pickle, mustard, and mayo.
US$4.94

Loaded Potato

Seasoned mashed potatoes, bacon, cheddar, sour cream and scallions.
US$4.94

Chipotle Chicken (Pollo Chipotle)

Hot. Tender shredded chicken, smokey chipotle peppers, sweet peppers, onions, and garlic.
US$4.94

Pork (Pernil)

Marinated, slow-cooked, Puerto Rican style.
US$4.94

Buffalo Chicken (Pollo Bufallo)

Tender shredded chicken, buffalo sauce.
US$4.94

Four Cheese (Cuatro Queso)

Queso Blanco, cheddar, mozzarella, and ricotta.
US$4.94

Philly Cheese Steak

Tender steak, peppers, onions, garlic and provolone.
US$4.94

Spinach & Feta (Espinaca Y Queso Feta)

Spinach, feta, garlic, and onions.
US$4.94

Shrimp & Mango Salsa (Camerones Y Salsa De Mango)

Shrimp sauteed with garlic, mango salsa, and fresh cilantro.
US$5.30

Bacon Mac &Cheese

Homemade mac and cheese with crispy bacon.
US$4.94

B.B.Q. Chicken (Pollo A La Barbacoa)

Tender shredded chicken, BBQ sauce, bacon, and mozzarella cheese.
US$4.94

Chorizo & Potato (Chorize & Pappas)

Spanish sausage, potato, peppers, onion, garil and cilantro.
US$4.94

Spicy Cheese

Four cheese with spicy chopped jalapeno.
US$4.94

Chipotle Beef (Carne Chipotle)

Hot. Ground beef, smokey chipotle peppers, sweet peppers, onions and garlic.
US$4.94

Broccoli & Cheese (Broccoli Y Queso)

Broccoli, garlic, scallots, and cheddar.
US$4.94

Pastelon

Seasoned ground beef, secret sofrito sauce with cheddar cheese (con queso cheddar), sweet plantains.
US$4.94

Asian Chicken (Pollo Asiatico)

Tender shredded chicken, spicy Asian sauce.
US$4.94

Nacho Empanada

Refried beans, mango salsa, and cheddar cheese.
US$4.94

Latin Shrimp (Camerones A Lo Latino)

Shrimp sauteed with peppers, onions, and Latin spices.
US$5.30

Veggie Lover (Vegan)

Broccoli, carrots, peppers, onions, celery, and garlic.
US$4.94

Sweet Plantain & Mozzarella (Plantanos Maduos Y Mozzarella)

Ripe plantains with mozzarella cheese.
US$4.94

Chipotle Beef & Sweet Plantain (Carne Chipotle Y Plantanos Maduros)

Ground beef, chipotle peppers, sweet peppers, onions, garlic, and sweet plantains.
US$4.94

Lunch - Empanadas

Lunch - Got'em by the Box

Any 10 Empanadas
US$44.50

Any 20 Empanadas
US$86.79

Any 15 Empanadas

Choice of many flavors.
US$66.89

Mini Mac & Cheese Ball (1 Ball)

Creamy homemade mac and cheese with panko bread crumbs.
US$3.99

Mini Loaded Baked Potato Ball (1 Ball)

Bacon, cheddar, sour cream, and scallions.
US$3.99

Sofrito Beef Potato Ball
US$6.15

Lunch - Potato, Mac & Cheese Balls

Lunch - Sides

Yellow Rice & Beans (Small - Pequeno)

Vegan, vegetarian.
US$4.85

Yellow Rice & Beans (Large - Grande)
US$9.75

Tostones

A savory green plantain with a crunch.
US$4.85

Sweet Plantains (Small - Pequeno)
US$4.85

Sweet Plantains (Large - Grande)
US$9.75

Chicken Tenders

4 piece. Choice of ketchup, honey mustard or no sauce.
US$9.59

Large Fiesta Fry

Fries made from Yuca
US$9.75

French Fries

Choice of ketchup, pink sauce or no sauce.
US$4.85

Small Fiesta Fry

Fries made from yuca
US$4.85

Green Sauce 2oz Cup

Medium Spice.
US$0.60

Sour Cream 2oz
US$0.60

Red Sauce 2 Oz

Spicy
US$0.60

Sour Cream 1oz
US$0.40

Green Sauce 1oz Cup

Medium spice.
US$0.40

Red Sauce 1oz Cup

Spicy.
US$0.40

Lunch - Sauce

Lunch - Desserts

Oreo Empanada

Ala mode (vanilla ice cream).
US$5.30

Stuffed Churro

With barvarian cream.
US$3.69

Apple Caramel Empanada

Ala mode (vanilla ice cream).
US$5.30

Guava & Cream Cheese Empanada

Guava and cream cheese empanada.
US$5.30

Oreo Empanada (A La Mode)

Served with icecream.
US$6.50

Apple Caramel Empanada A La Mode

Served with icecream.
US$6.50

Churo Sundae With Vanilla Ice Cream
US$4.29

20 Oz Bottle Drinks
US$3.45

2 Liter Soda
US$4.29

Fountain Drink 16oz
US$3.09

Fountain Drink 24oz
US$3.69

Lunch - Beverages

Lunch - Plant Based

Plant Based Lunch Special With Sides

2 plant based beef rice& beans, Sweet plantains and a fountain drink.
US$17.05

Plant Based Beef Empanada

Singular empanada.
US$5.89

2 Plant-Based Beef Empanada No Sides

Served with a fountain drink.
US$13.50

Plant Based Dinner Special

3 plant based beef rice & beans Sweet plantains and a fountain drink.
US$21.95

6 Wings
US$10.90

12 Wings
US$20.59

Lunch - Chicken Wings

Dinner - Dinner Special

3 Empanadas, Rice & Beans, Sweet Plantains & Fountain Drink (16 Oz.)
US$18.50

Chicken & Rice Soup (Large 16 Oz.)
US$6.69

Chicken & Rice Soup (Small 12 Oz.)
US$5.25

Dinner - Homemade Soup

Dinner - Empanadas

Traditional Chicken With Cheese

Tender shredded chicken seasoned with secret sofrito sauce with cheddar cheese. (con queso cheddar)
US$4.94

Traditional Beef With Cheese

Seasoned ground beef, secret sofrito sauce with cheddar cheese (con queso cheddar).
US$4.94

Traditional Beef (Carne Tradicional)

Seasoned ground beef, secret sofrito sauce.
US$4.94

Chipotle Chicken (Pollo Chipotle)

Hot. Tender shredded chicken, smokey chipotle peppers, sweet peppers, onions, and garlic.
US$4.94

Chicken Bacon Ranch (Pollo Ranchero)

Tender shredded chicken, bacon, ranch dressing, cheddar, and mozzarella cheese. (Aka uncle joey)
US$4.94

Pork (Pernil)

Marinated, slow-cooked, Puerto Rican style.
US$4.94

Traditional Chicken (Pollo Traditional)

Tender shredded chicken seasoned with secret sofrito sauce.
US$4.94

Loaded Potato

Seasoned mashed potatoes, bacon, cheddar, sour cream and scallions.
US$4.94

Shrimp & Mango Salsa (Camerones Y Salsa De Mango)

Shrimp sauteed with garlic, mango salsa, and fresh cilantro.
US$5.30

Cuban

Slow-cooked pork, ham, swiss, pickle, mustard, and mayo.
US$4.94

Bacon Mac &Cheese

Homemade mac and cheese with crispy bacon.
US$4.94

Four Cheese (Cuatro Queso)

Queso Blanco, cheddar, mozzarella, and ricotta.
US$4.94

Buffalo Chicken (Pollo Bufallo)

Tender shredded chicken, buffalo sauce.
US$4.94

Pastelon

Seasoned ground beef, secret sofrito sauce with cheddar cheese (con queso cheddar), sweet plantains.
US$4.94

Philly Cheese Steak

Tender steak, peppers, onions, garlic and provolone.
US$4.94

B.B.Q. Chicken (Pollo A La Barbacoa)

Tender shredded chicken, BBQ sauce, bacon, and mozzarella cheese.
US$4.94

Asian Chicken (Pollo Asiatico)

Tender shredded chicken, spicy Asian sauce.
US$4.94

Spinach & Feta (Espinaca Y Queso Feta)

Spinach, feta, garlic, and onions.
US$4.94

Broccoli & Cheese (Broccoli Y Queso)

Broccoli, garlic, scallots, and cheddar.
US$4.94

Latin Shrimp (Camerones A Lo Latino)

Shrimp sauteed with peppers, onions, and Latin spices.
US$5.30

Chorizo & Potato (Chorize & Pappas)

Spanish sausage, potato, peppers, onion, garil and cilantro.
US$4.94

Veggie Lover (Vegan)

Broccoli, carrots, peppers, onions, celery, and garlic.
US$4.94

Chipotle Beef (Carne Chipotle)

Hot. Ground beef, smokey chipotle peppers, sweet peppers, onions and garlic.
US$4.94

Nacho Empanada

Refried beans, mango salsa, and cheddar cheese.
US$4.94

Sweet Plantain & Mozzarella (Plantanos Maduos Y Mozzarella)

Ripe plantains with mozzarella cheese.
US$4.94

Chipotle Beef & Sweet Plantain (Carne Chipotle Y Plantanos Maduros)

Ground beef, chipotle peppers, sweet peppers, onions, garlic, and sweet plantains.
US$4.94

Any 10 Empanadas
US$44.50

Any 20 Empanadas
US$86.79

Any 15 Empanadas

Choice of many flavors.
US$66.89

Dinner - Got'em by the Box

Dinner - Potato, Mac & Cheese Balls

Mini Mac & Cheese Ball (1Ball)

Creamy homemade mac and cheese with panko bread crumbs.
US$3.99

Mini Loaded Baked Potato Ball (1 Ball)

Bacon, cheddar, sour cream, and scallions.
US$3.99

Yellow Rice & Beans (Large - Grande)
US$9.75

Yellow Rice & Beans (Small - Pequeno)

Vegan, vegetarian.
US$4.85

Sweet Plantains (Small - Pequeno)
US$4.85

Sweet Plantains (Large - Grande)
US$9.75

Tostones

A savory green plantain with a crunch.
US$4.85

French Fries

Choice of ketchup, pink sauce or no sauce.
US$4.85

Chicken Tenders

4 piece. Choice of ketchup, honey mustard or no sauce.
US$9.59

Small Fiesta Fry

Fries Made from Yuca
US$4.85

Large Fiesta Fry

Fries made from yuca
US$9.75

Dinner - Sides

Dinner - Sauce

Green Sauce 2oz Cup

Medium spice.
US$0.60

Red Sauce 2oz Cup

Spicy.
US$0.60

Sour Cream 2oz Cup
US$0.60

Green Sauce 1oz Cup

Medium spice.
US$0.40

Red Sauce 1oz Cup

Spicy.
US$0.40

Sour Cream 1oz Cup
US$0.40

Oreo Empanada

Ala mode (vanilla ice cream).
US$5.30

Apple Caramel Empanada

Ala mode (vanilla ice cream).
US$5.30

Stuffed Churro

With barvarian cream.
US$3.69

Guava & Cream Cheese Empanada

Guava and cream cheese empanada.
US$5.30

Oreo Empanada (A La Mode)

Served with icecream.
US$6.50

Churo Sundae With Vanilla Ice Cream
US$4.29

Apple Caramel Empanada A La Mode

Served with icecream.
US$6.50

Dinner - Desserts

Dinner - Beverages

20 Oz Bottle Drinks
US$3.45

2 Liter Soda
US$4.29

Fountain Drink 16oz
US$3.09

Fountain Drink 24oz
US$3.69

Plant Based Beef Empanada

Singular empanada.
US$5.89

Plant Based Dinner Special

3 plant based beef rice & beans Sweet plantains and a fountain drink.
US$21.95

Plant Based Lunch Special With Sides

2 plant based beef rice & beans Sweet plantains and a fountain drink.
US$17.05

2 Plant-Based Beef Empanada No Sides

Served with a fountain drink.
US$13.50

Dinner - Plant Based

Dinner - Chicken Wings

6 Wings
US$10.90

12 Wings
US$20.59